The Sustainability Governance Scorecard© (SGS) is an impact-research conducted to help improve the state of the world by speeding up learning from peers. SGS does not aim to measure the companies’ sustainability performance but seeks to identify how the best companies govern and conduct their sustainability efforts. It is intended to be utilized as an improvement tool for better governance of sustainability issues and presents best-practice examples of various sustainability governance steps to accelerate learning.

Board Skills Matrix

Recommendations

Top Performers in SGS 2022

A skills matrix identifies the skills, knowledge, experience, and capabilities desired of a board to enable it to meet both its current and future challenges and realize its opportunities. Disclosing a skills matrix is good governance and offers an opportunity for considered reflection on whether the board has the right skills and diversity for providing guidance and oversight on sustainability.

SGS2020
SGS2021
SGS2022
At least One Board Member
has Sustainability Skill
49
72
86
Publishes Skills Matrix
36
54
60
Skills Matrix Includes
Sustainability
8
34
43
  1. Link business requirements to board qualifications and make sustainability a board priority
  2. Disclose a board skills matrix
  3. Ensure relevant sustainability expertise as a board member skill
  4. Improve diversity to manage sustainability
  5. Boost productive dialogue in board meetings
  • African Rainbow Minerals
  • Albemarle
  • Aspen Pharmacare
  • Bharti Airtel
  • Exelon Corp
  • Exxaro Resources
  • Freeport-McMoRan
  • Gilead Sciences
  • Havells India
  • Kumba Iron Ore
  • National Grid UK
  • Nestle India
  • Pick n Pay Stores
  • Rio Tinto
  • Sasol
  • Sempra Energy
  • SSE
  • Stanley Black & Decker
  • Woolworths Holdings

Executive Compensation

Recommendations

Top Performers in SGS 2022

In order to focus management behavior on capturing opportunities from sustainability and ensure that sustainability practices are adopted as everyday practice in decision making, Boards need to make management explicitly accountable for the company’s environmental and social impact. By aligning executive compensation with strategic sustainability targets and tying performance payouts to non-financial sustainability metrics, Boards can sharpen management’s focus on sustainability issues.

SGS2020
SGS2021
SGS2022
Compensation Linked to
Environmental KPIs
29
32
48
Covers Environmental KPIs
12
19
30
Covers Social KPIs
27
29
45
Covers Governance KPIs
7
13
11
  1. Identify appropriate ESG metrics material to financial performance and align them with long-term strategy
  2. Link Executive Compensation to material sustainability / ESG targets
  3. Provide high-quality disclosure to signal commitment to sustainability
  4. Integrate sustainability into the performance management systems of the entire organization
  5. Prioritize Governance KPIs as crucial as social and environmental KPIs
  • Adidas
  • Ashok Leyland
  • Aspen Pharmacare
  • BMW
  • Duke Energy
  • GEA Group
  • Harmony
  • Hess Corp
  • Honeywell International
  • Linde plc
  • Puma

Targets & Results

Recommendations

Top Performers in SGS 2022

What gets measured, gets improved. Transparency on the material environmental, social, and governance performance results signals that it is monitoring progress toward sustainability goals. Best-in-class companies set short-term and long-term targets on material sustainability issues, report comprehensive results for their own operations with a geographical breakdown as well as across the value chain and evaluate their performance.

SGS2020
SGS2021
SGS2022
Sustainability Targets
for Business
76
81
87
Sustainability Targets
for Value Chain
29
40
40
Sustainability Results
for Business
99
99
99
Sustainability Results
for Value Chain
53
66
74
  1. Set ESG KPIs and SMART targets in line with what matters to focus attention on improving sustainability performance
  2. Measure and report ESG performance
  3. Assess results and share remedial action to address gap
  4. Cover all employees, geographies, and the supply chain
  5. Manage your company as well as your ecosystem
  6. Cooperate and partner for impact for a step-change in how we do business
  7. Develop reliable, consistent set of indicators to measure intangibles
  8. Cooperate for the development of a unified reporting framework
  9. Pursue sectoral collaboration to define what matters and invest in measurement and reporting systems
  10. Communicate the value of metrics and provide feedback on its usefulness for decision making
  • Adidas
  • Anglo American
  • Anglo American Platinum
  • Arçelik
  • CNH Industrial
  • Coca-Cola HBC
  • Coca-Cola İçecek
  • Croda International
  • GEA Group
  • Henkel
  • Hugo Boss
  • Lanxess
  • Merck
  • Migros Ticaret
  • NTPC
  • Puma
  • Unilever
  • United Utilities Group
  • Ülker Bisküvi

Board Oversight & Audit

Recommendations

Top Performers in SGS 2022

The board’s oversight role requires setting up an effective internal control mechanism, ensuring the independence of audit and strict compliance, monitoring ethics and business conduct within the company and its value chain, and transparency in external reporting and disclosure. Effective tracking of sustainability performance and communication to the board is essential for improving oversight of sustainability.

SGS2020
SGS2021
SGS2022
Independent Audit Covers
Sustainability Issues
80
81
81
Covers Environmental Issues
73
73
73
Covers Social Issues
67
68
69
Covers Governance Issues
58
66
67
Independent Audit Covers
Supply Chain
47
54
58
  1. Define the Board’s sustainability responsibilities
  2. Set up formal structures and ensure regular Board review of ESG issues
  3. Cascade sustainability responsibility across the organization
  4. Ensure internal and independent audit covers all material ESG issues, supply chain, and geographies
  5. Conduct board evaluation, integrate ESG issues into board evaluation and disclose results
  • Adidas
  • Alcoa Corp
  • Coca-Cola European Partners
  • Coca-Cola HBC
  • Coca-Cola İçecek
  • Colgate-Palmolive
  • Exxaro Resources
  • GlaxoSmithKline
  • Havells India
  • Hindalco Industries
  • Impala Platinum
  • NTPC
  • Pick n Pay Stores
  • Siemens Germany
  • Sun Pharma
  • Symrise
  • Unilever
  • Vodafone Group
  • Woolworths Holdings

Supply Chain Sustainability

Recommendations

Top Performers in SGS 2022

Many companies’ greatest sustainability risks and opportunities are in the supply chain. Leading companies in sustainability accept responsibility throughout their value chains and work with their suppliers to implement sustainability initiatives. This may involve utilizing their purchasing power to encourage, audit, collaborate with, and provide benchmarking and learning opportunities with its suppliers on key sustainability issues.

SGS2020
SGS2021
SGS2022
Supplier Code of Conduct
Covers Sustainability Issues
90
95
96
Supplier Assurance Process
Covers Sustainability Issues
75
86
85
Supply Chain Assurance Results
Covers Sustainability Issues
43
58
61
  1. Assume responsibility across the value chain
  2. Develop a code of conduct for the supply chain containing ESG issues
  3. Develop a comprehensive ESG assurance process for the supply chain
  • Adidas
  • Ashok Leyland
  • Dr Reddy’s Laboratories
  • Exelon Corp
  • Gail India
  • GEA Group
  • Havells India
  • Migros Ticaret
  • Reckitt Benckiser Group
  • Siemens Germany
  • Unilever

Link to SDGs and Ecosystem

Recommendations

Top Performers in SGS 2022

Managing your ecosystem includes taking responsibility for the environment, communities and networks in which the company operates. Ecosystem responsibility requires pursuing non-traditional partnerships between public, private and social spheres, or between competitors within the same industry to accelerate impact towards Sustainable Development Goals.

SGS2020
SGS2021
SGS2022
Links Strategy with
the SDGs
73
86
88
Links Results with
the SDGs
58
71
82
Links Targets with
the SDGs
50
57
  1. Link with strategy and prioritize SDGs
  2. Quantify your contribution for stakeholders
  3. Focus on a few SDGs that matters to drive impact
  4. Make it specific
  5. Set targets and measure progress
  6. Develop and share an action plan to address gaps
  7. Think of your ecosystem
  8. Partner for impact both at the sector level and systemic level
  • CNH Industrial
  • General Motors
  • Linde plc
  • PPG Industries
  • Tata Power
  • Whirlpool Corporation
  • Williams Companies

Learning & Development

Recommendations

Top Performers in SGS 2022

Integrating sustainability into the organization’s processes and culture requires a continuous learning climate. Lessons learned should be utilized to improve decision-making processes, skills gaps and required mindset changes need to be addressed through training and sustainability practices need to be integrated into the company’s culture.

SGS2020
SGS2021
SGS2022
Conducts
Environmental Training
48
52
49
Conducts
Social Training
92
95
96
Conducts
Governance Training
71
78
78
  1. Adopt a learning mindset, sustainability is a journey that requires continuous development
  2. Train your workforce in ESG
  3. Report results by geography, cover management and employees
  4. Think of building capacity in your ecosystem
  5. Establish a learning loop for continuous improvement by disclosing remedial action to address gaps
  6. Provide board leadership and oversight for deployment
  7. Incorporate lessons learned into the organizations processes and culture
  • Adidas
  • Anglo American Platinum
  • Associated British Foods
  • Atlantica Sustainable Infrastructure
  • Bayer
  • BMW
  • Cipla
  • Coca-Cola İçecek
  • Diageo
  • Emerson Electric
  • Gail India
  • Henkel
  • Linde plc
  • Mahindra & Mahindra
  • Merck
  • Migros Ticaret
  • Tüpraş
  • Unilever
  • United Utilities Group